The Ethics of Nuclear Energy
If war is much too serious a thing to be left to the military (Georges Clemenceau) ethics is much too important to be left to the professional ethicists. They are good at pontificating on general principles but poor at applying them to practical situations in a manner that would help the public. Some critics of nuclear energy, exploiting the vacuum, claim that the use of nuclear energy is unethical. As a result, there is a widely held view among the public that its use may be necessary but undesirable.
My position has been presented in the sources listed below, all in the public domain. Since several are not readily available links to them are given. In these I give reasons for believing that nuclear energy is ethical and I argue that much of the critics’ reasoning is faulty, based on a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the facts. The conclusions are that the use of nuclear energy, under proper regulatory control, is ethical for many applications, and that to ignore its potential for clean, affordable energy in an energy-hungry world would be unethical.
- Brief by J.A.L. Robertson on "Canada’s Domestic Nuclear Issues and International Nuclear Trade", Submitted to the Panels of the Interfaith Program on Public Awareness of Nuclear Issues, 1984 September 24
- "A Critique of the IPPANI Report: A Dissenter’s View", by J.A.L. Robertson, 1986
- "Positivism, objectivity, and facts", by J.A.L. Robertson, Ethics and Energy, Spring 1986, p.2
- "The Geometry of Nuclear Energy: Getting the Right Angle on the Ethics", by J.A.L. Robertson, Canadian Nuclear Society Bulletin, Vol. 13, No. 3, Fall 1992
- "Review of AECL’s Environmental Impact Statement", Submitted by J.A.L. Robertson to the Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste, Section 3.5 Ethics, 1996 January
- "Addendum to Review of AECL’s Environmental Impact Statement: A Submission by J.A.L. Robertson to the Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste, Issues Papers, IP-1 Ethical Considerations", 1996 February
- "Comments by J.A.L. Robertson on Submissions PH PUB.080 & 085 by Inter-Church Uranium Committee Education Cooperative", 1996 April 10
- "Comments by J.A.L. Robertson on Submission PH PUB.043 by P. Timmerman (CCEER) to the Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste", 1996 April 5
- "Comments by J.A.L. Robertson on Submission PH PUB.124 by United Church of Canada to the Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste", 1996 April 26
- "Verbal Presentation by J.A.L. Robertson to Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste on AECL’s Environmental Impact Statement, Section 4. Ethics", 1996 May 2
- "Comments by J.A.L. Robertson on Submission PH2 PUB.021 by CCEER to the Environmental Assessment Panel for Canada’s Nuclear Fuel Waste, Section 3, Essays: Deeper into the Issues", 1996 October 29
- "Decide the Nuclear Issues for Yourself: Nuclear need not be Unclear", by J.A.L. Robertson, Chapter 13 "Ethics: A Personal View", 2000
- "Nuclear Waste: Exploring the Ethical Dilemmas by Lois M. Wilson: A critique by J.A.L. Robertson", 2001
- "Practical Ethics - An Oxymoron?" by J.A.L. Robertson, 2003
|